For a long time I have watched the "Christian celebrity" phenomenon blast off before it eventually crash landed on top of the American evangelical church. What this celebrity phenomenon illustrates, among many things, is that evangelicalism as a whole has very little spiritual discernment. We want 'results' even when it means succumbing to worldliness, pragmatism, or you fill in the blank. We desperately want to be viewed as relevant, hip, innovative, and successful.
In this vein, Phil Johnson wisely notes- Dr. Trueman is right to point out that it is a uniquely American evangelical phenomenon to foster these cults of celebrity and to encourage each wave of superstars to push the limits of sobriety and propriety further than the last superstar did. American evangelicalism has become a large jingoistic freak show. Sadly, some of today's evangelicals seem to think that's something to gloat about. The Evangelical church seems more than willing to justify questionable behavior and/or salacious speech if the person or church in question are popular enough.
Before I get into that issue let me first say this. As in all areas of life it is very difficult not to fall into an "extremist ditch" when fleshing out the Christian faith. For example, some envious "no name" pastors have been hypercritical of any "well known" pastor, any "best-selling" Christian author, and every local church larger than their own. It comes as no surprise then that these same jealous critics have been skeptical of even the most orthodox of mega conferences such as Together for the Gospel, Ligonier Conference, or the Shepherds' Conference.
On the other hand, quite a few Christians believe popularity equals not only "success" but also ministry "fruitfulness." People in this camp often assume that big buildings and large crowds validate someone's theology (note 1 Corinthians 1-2) as well as their ministry methodology (note 1 Corinthians 3-4). Popularity and fame have provided certain choice "evangelical celebrities" and/or mega churches a free pass on valid critiques from within the larger body of Christ. From the Elephant Room debacle to you fill in the blank. After all, "God must be blessing so and so." "Look at how fast his church has grown!" "Look how many books they've sold." "Look how many unchurched people attend there satellite services; etc, etc." Pastor Jerry Wragg and Dr. Carl Trueman have voiced some of these same concerns here and here. Dr. David Wells also addresses this problem in his classic work, The Courage To Be Protestant: Truth lovers, Marketers, and Emergents in the Postmodern World.








