Friday, April 29, 2016

Real World Scenarios: How Would You Respond If ____________

Photo Credit: getallgist.com
What would you do?

Scenario 1: Two women ask to meet with you. They are legally married residents of your state. They want to meet with you because they would like to start coming to church regularly.  They have been recently listening to your sermons online and like them a lot.  They have two children, one in Grade 3 and one in Grade 8.  They each say that they believe that Jesus Christ is their Lord and Savior.  They wanted to meet to see if it would be OK for them to start coming to church regularly, along with their children.  They want their kids to be involved in the children and youth ministries. 

What do you do next? Why?

Here is what I think I would do
1)    I would identify evidences of God’s common grace.  “It is wonderful that you want your children to be a part of a Bible-teaching church.  It’s obvious that you love them very much.”
2)    I would explain that our church family is always encouraged when guests visit and explain that our ministry exists to share the gospel of Jesus Christ with the local community.  In other words, “You are welcome to come and observe any of our services.” 
3)    I would graciously explain our doctrinal position concerning marriage and sexuality reasoning from the Scriptures so they see this is what God’s Word teaches.
4)    If the Spirit provided an opportunity to do so I would share the gospel.  I know some pastors would choose not to “turn away” or “offend” a potential “seeker.”  However, in following the evangelistic pattern of the Master one must preach the truth in love understanding that tomorrow is not guaranteed to any one of us (James 4:13-15; Heb. 9:27).  Jesus went for the jugular with the rich, young ruler and with the immoral Samaritan woman.  Having said that, He also demonstrated radical love and compassion.  In John 8 Jesus provides the perfect example of grace (“let him who is without sin cast the first stone”) and truth (“go and sin no more”).  As the Master evangelist Jesus has left us with the perfect example.
5)     At some point, I would talk about how the meeting went with another pastor or lay leader.  A leadership team provides mutual encouragement and helpful insights that in turn will help me be a better servant. The “leader among leaders” must remain a lifelong learner.

Here is how Pastor Phil Johnson responded to the same scenario:
"I'd assure them that they are welcome to attend our church and listen to the teaching, but they would not qualify for membership and their participation in ministry and activities would therefore be limited. 
I'd carefully explain (giving a biblical rationale) that: 
1) We regard their lifestyle as sinful; 
2) We don't recognize their "marriage" as a legitimate expression of what marriage is supposed to portray; 
3) We don't accept their profession of faith because of their persistence in a soul-destroying sin; 
4) that would mean that they would be excluded from the Lord's table; and
5) If they persisted in publicly professing to be Christians, then in obedience to 1 Cor. 5:11 we would be forced to ban them from even attending our services. Understanding that is the position our commitment to Scripture demands, if they still want to attend so that they can be exposed to the teaching, they would be more than welcome to come.  (see also Phil's article on same sex attraction and impure lust).

Here is how Pastor Sam Allberry responded to a similar set of questions in his book is God anti-Gay?

Allberry suggests not talking about the issue of homosexuality during this meeting. He writes, "But my initial concern is for them to know they are welcome and that we are glad to have them with us, and for them to come under the sound of the gospel through the church's regular ministry. Another way to put this is to say that I would rather start at the centre and work outwards, then start at the edge and work in." (p. 65; is God anti-gay?).  In other words, Allberry counsels pastors to not discuss the issue or bring it up unless they directly ask you about it.  "Sometimes there is the danger of Christians thinking that a gay couple needs to be confronted about their sexuality almost the moment they walk through the door; that this needs to be talked about immediately and the couple told what the Bible's teaching is on the whole issue.  This is simply not the case" (p. 64).  

What about you reader?  What would you do nextWhy?